Business Transfers and Tax Debts: Temporal Effectiveness of the Pending Tax Liabilities Certificate
The Italian Supreme Court of Cassation, with Order No. 26077/2026, clarified the limits of the release effect granted by the certificate of pending tax liabilities issued pursuant to Article 14 of Legislative Decree No. 472/1997. The Supreme Court ruled that a negative certificate obtained several months prior to the closing is insufficient to release the purchaser from joint and several liability for the transferor’s tax debts if it does not accurately reflect the situation as of the actual transfer date. The ruling highlights how contractual clauses requiring a second updated certificate at closing demonstrate awareness of the provisional nature of the first, with the consequence that the purchaser will be jointly and liable for the tax claims formalized in the most recent certificate.
Legislative Decree 231 and Cooperative Compliance: Guidelines from Circular No. 6/E
In Circular No. 6/E, the Italian Revenue Agency formalized the strategic role of Compliance Model 231 within the cooperative compliance regime, confirming that its adoption is suitable for certifying the prevention of tax fraud risks and the company’s low tax risk profile. To effectively integrate these systems, Compliance Model 231 must map tax-related predicate offences and establish structured reporting flows between the Supervisory Body (OdV) and the head of tax compliance. In the absence of regulatory details on practical coordination procedures, companies are urged to implement integrated governance between Compliance Model 231 and the Tax Control Framework (TCF) to prevent duplications and ensure efficient controls.
Qualification of Shareholder Payments: Evidentiary Value of the Payment Purpose Description
With Judgment No. 1443/2026, the Court of Appeal of Turin revisited the distinction between shareholder loans (entitling the lender to repayment) and equity contributions (allocated to capital reserves). The judges reaffirmed that the burden of proof regarding the loan nature rests with the party seeking reimbursement and that the absence of a term or interest rate does not preclude its classification as a loan. The decision assigns decisive presumptive weight to the payment purpose description indicated in the bank transfer (e.g., “personal loan”), further confirming that the alleged simulation of the loan for tax avoidance purposes cannot be demonstrated through testimonies given by the company’s or the shareholder’s consultants, due to the prohibitions set forth in Articles 1417 and 2722 of the Italian Civil Code.
Shell Companies and Abuse of Law: Burden of Proof for Non-Fiscal Reasons
Tax practice and anti-abuse regulations (Article 10-bis of Law No. 212/2000) classify as potentially abusive the incorporation of a capital company lacking direct economic activity that systematically retains profits to postpone the Personal Income Tax (IRPEF) burden inherent in the two-tier taxation mechanism of corporate income. However, the transaction is not sanctionable if supported by valid, non-marginal extra-fiscal reasons, including organizational or management purposes. Regarding the burden of proof, the Tax Authority must demonstrate the structural absence of economic activity and the avoidance purpose since incorporation, while the taxpayer bears the burden of proving the existence of extra-fiscal motivations or that the operational stagnation resulted from unforeseeable external factors.
Quorums and Abstentions in Joint-Stock Companies (S.p.A.) and Limited Liability Companies (S.r.l.): New Guidelines from the Triveneto Notaries
In recent guidelines H.B.44 and I.B.35, the Interregional Committee of the Notaries of the Triveneto region reaffirmed that, as a general rule, abstention in both S.p.A. and S.r.l. meetings is equivalent to a negative vote for the purpose of calculating deliberative quorums. The sole legal exception concerns abstentions due to a conflict of interest in S.p.A. (Article 2368 of the Italian Civil Code), which instead reduces the calculation base. For S.r.l., the guideline introduces significant statutory flexibility: exercising the organizational autonomy guaranteed by Article 2479-bis of the Italian Civil Code, companies may introduce a clause excluding abstaining members from the quorum computation, anchoring the majority exclusively to expressly favorable or contrary votes.
Payments for Future Capital Increases: Conditions for Restitution and Transferability of Claims
Supreme Court Order No. 27948 clarifies the nature of shareholder payments made towards a future capital increase, defining them as a conditional claim. Restitution cannot be demanded ad nutum (at will); rather, the claim becomes current and enforceable only when the capital increase proves impossible or is not resolved upon, without requiring an explicit “non-increase” resolution. A shareholder’s exit from the corporate structure does not extinguish the legal cause of the payment nor does it grant an immediate right to reimbursement; however, the shareholder may transfer their corporate stake while retaining the claim, or transfer the claim separately. In the event of an independent transfer of the restitution claim, the warranty for the non-existence of the credit does not apply, as such payments generate a genuine creditor position rather than a mere risk-capital contribution.